“The Substance” Earns Best Picture Nomination at…

The Rising Presence of Horror at the Oscars

Horror films rarely capture the spotlight at the Oscars, especially in top-tier categories. However, a few exceptions exist. “Silence of the Lambs” broke barriers in 1991, claiming Best Picture, among others. Yet, the years surrounding this win saw the genre primarily recognized for technical achievements. Sound mixing, costume, and makeup often secure nominations, much like this year’s “Nosferatu.”

Shifting the Spotlight

Notably, some Best Actress wins have acknowledged horror performances. Kathy Bates in “Misery” and Natalie Portman in “Black Swan” triumphed. Jodie Foster’s win for “Silence of the Lambs” also stands out. Despite these moments, horror hasn’t become a consistent presence on the awards circuit. It seems the Academy favors horror with dramatic sophistication, steering clear of gore.

This year, “The Substance” by Coralie Fargeat, marks a potential pivot. It’s nominated for Best Picture, Best Actress (Demi Moore), and Best Director. This inclusion raises eyebrows and expectations.

A New Kind of Horror

“The Substance” revels in body horror, delving into age and beauty with a relentless approach. Elisabeth Sparkle, played by Demi Moore, confronts being replaced in her exercise show as she turns 50. A radical treatment, The Substance, offers her eternal youth. Addiction ensues, and transformation carries the risk of destruction. Margaret Qualley co-stars, playing the younger version of Elisabeth, known as Sue.

Fargeat excels with practical effects that enhance the narrative. Gore abounds, yet it’s carefully crafted to support the story. The film’s visceral elements challenge viewers to engage deeply. A glossy aesthetic emerges with Sue’s introduction, emphasizing her renewed allure and underscoring the obsessive pursuit of youth.

A Proud Stand for Horror

In another era, “The Substance” might have been dismissed as trashy. Today, it stands proud within the body horror genre, unashamedly brash and blunt. Its nomination could signify a shift in the Academy’s perceptions. Lauded for its unapologetic satire, the film echoes Brian Yuzna’s “Society,” highlighting the grotesque facets of human ambition and vanity.

Potential for Change

While “The Substance” doesn’t chase awards, its acknowledgment may correct historical biases. Controversies persist regarding Oscar selections, but nominations spotlight underrepresented films. This visibility offers wider audiences a chance to engage with the genre.

Horror’s presence at the Oscars hints at evolving tastes among critics. Acknowledging horror’s merits enriches award shows traditionally dominated by dramas and biopics. As more horror films join the mix, they challenge established norms and vie for golden statues alongside historical narratives and indie dramas.