Fanfic Vibes and Just Yikes!

What If…? Season 3: A Surprising Turn for Marvel’s Animated Series

Marvel’s What If…? Season 3 recently wrapped up with a finale that left fans buzzing. This season, known for introducing new characters, sparked controversies and curious narratives. One episode raised eyebrows with an odd storyline featuring Howard the Duck and Darcy Lewis getting married and having a child, with a peculiar twist involving Darcy seemingly “laying an egg.”

A Season of Surprises and Criticism

While surprises were plentiful, so was criticism. The season currently holds the lowest audience score of any What If…? installment on Rotten Tomatoes, lingering at a mere 39%. Critics weren’t much kinder, offering the lowest critical score yet at 80%. Among the critics was former X-Men ’97 showrunner Beau DeMayo, who didn’t hold back in his assessment.

DeMayo took to social media, calling the season a “yikes” experience. He lamented its lack of depth, describing the episodes as lacking substance. "To me, it feels like fanfic," he declared. DeMayo criticized the dialogue as flat and the plotlines as strange.

Behind the Scenes Changes

This season marked a change in creative hands, with AC Bradley stepping back and Matthew Chauncey taking over as writer and producer. DeMayo mentioned this transition, implying it affected the show’s quality. Jokingly, he remarked that while improvement was possible, he had more pressing matters than offering detailed feedback.

Moreover, DeMayo managed to stir conversation by mentioning the creative team’s composition. He pointed out that the team was entirely white, which he suggested contributed to the show’s vibe—remarking, "Marvel likes that vibe." This statement added fuel to his already fiery critique.

A Troubled History and Context

DeMayo, previously pivotal in the success of X-Men ’97, faced his own controversies. Despite the series’ acclaim—renewed for multiple seasons before even airing—the behind-the-scenes drama surfaced. DeMayo’s firing became public, linked to allegations of sexual misconduct. A Disney spokesperson confirmed his termination was due to “egregious” findings in an internal investigation.

Looking Ahead

The ripple effects of DeMayo’s critiques and revelations have cast a shadow over What If…? Season 3. As Marvel fans process this latest chapter, questions linger about the show’s future direction. The series, known for exploring alternate realities, now faces its own crossroads. How fans and critics react could shape its narrative moving forward.

What If…? Season 3 has left its mark—both intriguing and divisive. Whether you loved or loathed this season, it’s clear Marvel’s animated universe continues to provoke thought and stir conversation. How do you feel about What If…? Season 3? Share your thoughts in the comments below!