Agatha Harkness: A Power Misunderstood or a Deadly Curse?
By August Tales
In the latest episode of Agatha All Along, titled “Darkest Hour / Wake Thy Power,” the story took an unexpected and chilling turn. The narrative midpoint brought wild developments, including the shocking death of Alice (Ali Ahn). This event not only shattered the coven’s unity but also forced Agatha (Kathryn Hahn) and her companions—Lilia (Patti LuPone) and Jen (Sasheer Zamata)—into dangerous territory. However, the unmasking of Teen’s (Joe Locke) true identity caught the group off guard, sending them plummeting into a mysterious mud pit, shifting the entire tone of the series.
The Witch We Thought We Knew
Agatha Harkness is no stranger to power and peril. To fully grasp her complexities, we revisit her introduction in WandaVision. In its eighth episode, “Previously On,” audiences learned about Agatha’s tragic past. In 1693, her coven, led by her mother Evanora, attempted to execute her for delving into forbidden magic. Rather than submit to her fate, Agatha unleashed her power, draining life and magic from her attackers. That grim episode serves as both an origin and a warning, revealing a hint of the deadly capabilities that now resurface.
This past encounter sets the stage for “Darkest Hour”. But the real question is: are Agatha’s actions driven by sinister intent, or is she merely a victim of forces beyond her control?
A Tragic Sacrifice
Alice’s death in the latest episode complicates our perception of Agatha’s powers. During a chaotic moment, the spirit of Evanora briefly takes control of Agatha, forcing Alice to intervene. However, Agatha unintentionally absorbs Alice’s magic, killing her in the process. Instead of reveling in her newfound power, Agatha appears horrified. Her reaction hints at the possibility that she might not fully control her powers—raising questions about whether the magic absorption is a curse rather than a gift.
Agatha’s shock following Alice’s death reveals an internal struggle. This wasn’t a calculated kill; instead, it feels like an unwanted consequence. As viewers, we are left wondering if her powers function more as a reflex than a deliberate act.
Power or Curse?
What if Agatha’s ability to absorb magic is beyond her control? If true, this revelation forces us to reconsider her actions, both past and present. In 1693, she may not have intended to destroy her coven but acted out of pure instinct. The idea of power as a curse rather than a choice changes how we view her. Agatha may carry the burden of a power that turns against those she cares for, making her an unwilling villain.
This episode reframes Agatha’s story, revealing that her fearsome reputation may be more a shield than a weapon. Misunderstood by her peers and feared for abilities she cannot fully harness, Agatha’s harsh demeanor might be a coping mechanism—her way of ensuring survival in a world that mistrusts magic.
A Misunderstood Villain or a Tragic Hero?
Alice’s death, now seen in this new light, adds a layer of tragedy to the narrative. It wasn’t a calculated act of malice but a devastating accident that only deepens the coven’s distrust. Agatha’s powers, shrouded in misunderstanding, create fractures within the group, leaving her isolated and fueling further conflict.
“Agatha All Along” continues to peel back the layers of its characters, inviting viewers to reconsider their assumptions. Each episode exposes more of Agatha’s complex nature, compelling audiences to question whether she is the villain we first thought—or if she is simply a woman navigating the dangerous weight of misunderstood magic.
New episodes stream every Wednesday at 9 p.m. ET on Disney+, offering more revelations about the life of this enigmatic witch.
Read this article and more at August Tales Comics. Your go-to site for trade paperback exchanges and comic book news! Trade. Read. Repeat.
#comics #comicbooks #graphicnovel #graphicnovels #augusttales
Image credit: comicbook.com
